Bishop Richard Allen, founder of the AME Church, claimed common cause with the American revolutionaries but had to urge them to rise to their principles.
Bishop Richard Allen

Introduction

Many African Americans of the Revolutionary era claimed common cause with the American patriots—and began demanding recognition of their own rights almost before the ink dried on the Declaration. Their stories demonstrate what, for Americans, patriotism requires.

Recently I had the opportunity to discuss the question, “Should patriotism be taught in public schools?” with a panel of citizens gathered by the groups Braver Angels and Courageous Conversations About Our Schools. Panelists were selected to represent a range of political views. Yet no one argued that patriotism can be taught directly. At most, panelists felt, students can be taught what the country has been and what its founders hoped it would become.

American political principles—our affirmation that human beings are all equally entitled to certain fundamental rights, which underlies our understanding of free government—were set forth in our Declaration. Afterwards, our founders imperfectly implemented those principles in our Constitution. Many teachers I’ve talked with encourage students to feel themselves part of a great unfinished experiment testing whether free government can work and endure. They hope students will see our history as a long process of perfecting the experiment, so that at last everyone’s rights are protected. Panelists as a whole seemed to agree; patriotism for an American, they thought, entails a commitment to make the country a better place.

But not all students process the study of American history in this way. Some can see only Americans’ repeated departures from their principles. An audience member challenged the panelists,  pointing to students who don’t see  American political ideals reflected in their daily life. Some have experienced racism, others a severe poverty . Looking at their more fortunate classmates, they conclude that the Declaration’s assertion of human equality was not intended to include people like themselves. How can these students trust the promises of the American founding?   

One panelist responded by pointing to efforts like those led by Martin Luther King, Jr. to secure for all the rights claimed in our Declaration. “King leveraged those words [of the Declaration] to bring about extraordinary change in this country,” the panelist said. Another recalled Ray Charles, who with the help of producer Quincy Jones recorded a moving version of America the Beautiful in 1972, leading with a verse honoring Americans who fought in the Civil War to liberate the enslaved. In both cases, influential African Americans encouraged their fellow citizens to rise to their principles—by reminding them of the promises they had earlier made, or of their prior willingness to keep those promises.

Powerful as these examples are, I found them somewhat problematic. They brought to mind a teacher friend’s comment on the rushed way American history is presented in the usual survey course. “Teachers march students through all the main events and major figures, preparing students for achievement tests. Students come away with the impression that African Americans were relentlessly oppressed until Dr. King arrived—when, finally, the people stood up for their rights. That really does a disservice both to students of color and to the history itself.”

In fact, marginalized groups in this country—African Americans in particular—began demanding recognition of their rights almost before the ink dried on the Declaration. The Bostonian Prince Hall, a free Black, petitioned the Massachusetts House of Burgesses to abolish slavery in 1777. Four years later, an enslaved woman known as “Mum Bett”— who called herself Elizabeth Freeman—found a lawyer who filed suit for her and a man named Brom, arguing that their enslavement violated the Massachusetts constitution. Freeman and Brom won their case. Subsequently, a series of cases concerning an enslaved man named Quock Walker, who argued he had been promised freedom by his late master, culminated in a 1783 ruling by the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts declaring slavery a violation of the state constitution. By pursuing justice for themselves, Freeman and Walker brought about the abolition of slavery throughout Massachusetts.

If the American affirmation of human liberty as grounded in human equality justifies Americans’ love of country, it is not because we lately began aligning our practices with these principles. It is because the principles are so powerful that they evoked calls for reform from the very beginning. They inspired those excluded by custom and prejudice from the promises of equality and liberty to immediately claim them. While learning what the American founders said and did, students should also learn about those who called out the founders’ inconsistencies. David Hackett Fisher persuasively calls African Americans who did the latter “Black founders.” They enlarged and corrected other Americans’ understanding of what our principles mean.

Phillis Wheatley called herself an American patriot while criticizing slavery.Their stories are little known yet not difficult to find. Phillis Wheatley, for example, began life in this country as a small and sickly enslaved girl of seven. Yet she grew up to become arguably the best-known poet of the Revolution. She did not easily gain this status. As Henry Louis Gates details, the adolescent Wheatley appeared before a panel of eighteen eminient Bostonians who questioned her until assured of her deep familiarity with classical and enlightenment models and the sincerity of her ideas. Wheatley called herself an American patriot. In a poem she dedicated to the Earl of Dartmouth, who sympathized with the American revolutionaries, Wheatley explained herself. She likened Americans’ resentment of Britain’s tyrannical impositions to her own father’s outrage when his daughter was captured and carried away by slave traders.:

Should you, my lord, while you peruse my song,
Wonder from whence my love of Freedom sprung,
Whence flow these wishes for the common good,
By feeling hearts alone best understood,

I, young in life, by seeming cruel fate

Was snatch’d from Afric’s fancy’d happy seat:
What pangs excruciating must molest,
What sorrows labour in my parent’s breast?

Steel’d was that soul and by no misery mov’d
That from a father seiz’d his babe belov’d:
Such, such my case. And can I then but pray
Others may never feel tyrannic sway?

Certainly, in telling the truth of her own bondage in her poetry, Wheatley told it “slant”—yet she told it, at the same time disproving racist claims of the intellectual inferiority of African Americans.

Similarly, Richard Allen, founder of the African Methodist Episcopal Church, repeatedly protested the unequal treatment of African Americans during the early republic. Born into slavery in 1760, Allen experienced a religious conversion while a teenager, then carefully plotted his own emancipation. In his autobiography, Allen tells how he and his brother brought their master to Christianity, then undertook extra work to purchase their own freedom. Afterwards, Allen became a highly effective traveling evangelist. In time he was asked to join the preaching staff of Grace Methodist Episcopal Church in Philadelphia. There, his evangelistic efforts aroused the resentment of white church members. When a deacon directed Black parishioners to segregated seating in the balcony, Allen and his friend Absalom Jones led a dramatic walkout. Allen writes that this event occurred during the summer of the Constitutional Convention. Other evidence suggests it occurred later, but Allen recorded a date that would underline his congregation’s right to self-government.

Afterwards, although Allen and Jones became leaders of two different Black congregations (Jones took orders as an Anglican priest, while Allen remained a Methodist), they continued collaborating. Having already founded the Free African Society, the first major Black mutual aid organization, they also served the larger Philadelphia community. When Dr. Benjamin Rush asked them to care for victims of Philadelphia’s 1791 yellow  fever epidemic, Allen and Jones organized a small army of African Americans who nursed those afflicted and buried those who died, at risk to their own lives.

Some students learn that, during the Revolution, British General Dunmore promised freedom to escaping slaves who fought with the loyalists. How many learn that Black soldiers fought also with the revolutionaries? One historian estimates that at times they comprised 10% of the Continental Army. Few students learn of James Forten, a free Black who at the age of 14 went to sea as a privateer for the American Patriots, or of his eventual capture by the British and his refusal to desert when offered a servant’s place in the family of a British officer. “I have been taken prisoner for the liberties of my country, and never will prove a traitor to her interest,” Forten reportedly said. After the war he apprenticed himself to a sailmaker and proved so competent that he eventually inherited the business. He also became an outspoken abolitionist.

To count these people among the American founders is not to say they achieved the liberty that our founding documents promised them. Although claiming common cause with the revolutionaries, they faced racist discrimination. Once released from slavery, Wheatley battled the hostility free Blacks faced in 18th-century Massachusetts. She married an enterprising free Black man, but his ventures failed, and she died young, in poverty. Allen did not soon establish his right to lead the congregation he built. He founded the separate AME denomination in 1815, after resisting repeated efforts by the Methodist hierarchy to seize control of his church. These efforts finally ended when the Pennsylvania Supreme Court affirmed his congregation’s ownership of the sanctuary they had built with their own hands. To count Wheatley, Allen and others among the founders is to say that at the beginning of our national life they urged us toward the reforms through which we have broadened the application of our principles.

During the long abolition and civil rights struggles, later generations built on the work of the Black founders. Progress in self-government is rarely swift and never assured. It depends on the determination of each new generation. As one panelist in the Braver Angels conversation pointed out, most of our patriotic feelings are bound up with the stories we tell about our ancestors. We remember how they struggled to build lives in this country, while insisting that America make good on the promises of liberty and equality. Teachers who help students learn these stories—and figure out the roles they will play as American history continues—encourage patriotism in the best sense.



About The Peoria Project

Peoria is remembered for the speech Abraham Lincoln gave there in 1854. This act of statesmanship began a great struggle to preserve American self-government, which today seems no less imperiled than it was then. Although lacking Lincoln’s depth of understanding and eloquence of pen, the Peoria Project seeks to assist in the current struggle to preserve self-government.

Read more.